Insurance carriers track which attorneys take cases to verdict and which typically settle quickly, and they price offers accordingly. Trial readiness affects how a case is negotiated, which is why it’s central to how this practice operates.
The Leverage
A case is worth what the other side believes you're willing to do with it.
The majority of personal injury cases settle before reaching a courtroom. Many plaintiff’s lawyers run a settlement-focused practice, and insurance carriers are familiar with that approach.
Carriers track which attorneys are known for trying cases and which typically settle, and this can affect how they approach negotiations. A trial-ready file, from an attorney with verdicts to his name, is often evaluated differently before a case ever nears a jury.
Two Kinds of Practice
The same case, valued two ways.
MOST FIRMS
A settlement focused approach
A client is signed, a demand is developed, and negotiation begins.
Experts and discovery are typically developed later, if a case doesn’t resolve.
This is a common approach, and one insurance carriers are familiar with.
Offers may reflect the likelihood that a case won’t go to trial.
THIS PRACTICE
A trial focused approach
Case preparation begins with trial in mind, from the first call.
Experts are retained early, and the file is documented to a jury standard.
Cases have been tried to verdict in California state and U.S. federal court.
Insurer offers can reflect this preparation before a suit is even filed.
The Method
How a case is built for trial, from the first call to the courtroom.
01
Intake
Built for trial from the first call.
The trial theme is identified at intake rather than developed later. Evidence, including vehicle data, scene conditions, surveillance, and electronic records, is preserved while it’s still available, since cases are strongest when documented early.
02
Discovery
Comprehensive discovery, experts early.
Liability and damages are developed in parallel. Medical, biomechanical, and economic experts are retained early, so the file is complete well before any mediation.
03
Negotiation
Settlement from a position of readiness.
By the time settlement is discussed, the file is trial-ready. Most cases resolve at this stage, typically at a number that reflects genuine trial preparation rather than an early-stage estimate.
04
Trial
To verdict, when the offer doesn’t reflect the case.
When a case isn’t valued fairly in negotiation, it can be tried to a jury in California Superior Court or U.S. federal court. That option remains available throughout, and it factors into how cases are evaluated earlier on.
Training
Two of the most selective trial programs in the country.
CAALA
GRADUATE
Plaintiff’s Trial Academy
Consumer Attorneys Association of Los Angeles
A selective trial advocacy program taught by some of California’s most accomplished plaintiff’s lawyers. Voir dire, opening, cross-examination, and damages, practiced the way they happen in a real courtroom.
ABOTA
GRADUATE
Jack Daniels Trial Academy
American Board of Trial Advocates
An intensive, invitation-based courtroom-craft program taught by experienced civil trial lawyers and former judges. ABOTA membership requires participation in actual jury trials tried to verdict.
A pedestrian was intentionally struck by a motorist. The defendant disputed causing the incident at all. The case was tried to a unanimous jury verdict in United States federal court.
U.S. FEDERAL COURT
UNANIMOUS JURY
LIABILITY DISPUTED
“
The point of trial readiness is not the trial itself. It is the leverage that comes from being known for taking cases the distance.